https://t.co/soX2PRRhRg
— Rob Maness (@RobManess) October 7, 2026
@Supersonic_Red I’m starting to question if they (and Canada!) can even be trusted in Five Eyes any more.
— Rand Simberg (@Simberg_Space) October 7, 2026
[Early-afternoon update]
The Systems Are Holding. The Question Is for How Long. https://t.co/u2YVlStVSn
— Supersonic Redhead🛫 (@Supersonic_Red) October 7, 2026
“If there is a broader security problem in Britain, we obviously need to know whether Fairford was an isolated vulnerability or an indication of something more systemic.”
It is systemic in that everyone lacks the proper defenses. Are our own bases and ports in the USA protected against a spiderweb like attack? No.
Is it a systemic problem with Britain? Yes. Their Navy has atrophied along with the rest of their military and governance.
The good news is that we are working on some systems. On the southern border, we have been shooting down cartel drones with directed energy weapons. We have 9 ships with directed energy weapons. More traditional anti aircraft weapons are being developed, EW capabilities expanded, multirole autonomous ships will be numerous, and anti drone weapons at the unit and soldier level. Oh, and we can turn Greenland into an airbase.
Other good news is the Europe is finally taking defense matters seriously instead of just talking about how mean Trump is. But will they move fast enough? Trump is moving with Muskian urgency.
The sea lanes are contested, which requires a vigorous presence to maintain and might require boots on the ground. The focus has been on Iran and their proxies but the area to watch is the side of the bab al mandab across from Yemen. Many countries have a shared interest, so hopefully many act on it.
Greenland as a base poses unique and serious logistical challenges as a base of operations. Not saying it can’t be done. But it won’t be “on the cheap”.
Our strategic strength is our logistics.
It wouldn’t be cheap but we also wouldn’t have to deal with the backstabbing British.
Col. Maness strikes me as a serious person who has held serious responsibilities. History shows time and again, unserious governments and their militaries get conquered.
I read the two stories. The “Nuclear Problem” analysis is dishonest. First, this is a US problem not a UK or Iran problem. It’s the responsibility of the US to secure its own logistics not allies not involved in that war or the enemy that the US is attacking.
As to Five Eye cooperation, there is no indication of a problem here.
The US in important ways can’t “lock down the approaches” to its bases either. For example, the Whiteman Air Force Base where the only B-2 bomber group is stationed has I-80 pass on the north side to within 15 miles of the base. That’s close enough for drone attacks and there are public roads that get much closer than that.
It’s dishonest to demand security guarantees of an ally that the US can’t/won’t provide for its own bases! And of course, a non sequitur to then jump from that to claim that the UK can’t defend its own nuclear weapons systems.
Why should they continue to be held? Even from a military sense, what’s to gain here? Is there any reason to expect them to say, attack Fairford again? One of the things the author misses is that there’s a lot of recent activity from enemies and potential enemies using uninformed proxies who don’t realize they’re part of a military operation.
Having said that, I’m fine with reexamining UK’s role in US nuclear deterrence (from a US-centric view) as long as the US similarly is reexamined. After all, the US carries the lion’s share of the nuclear deterrence load, and the Fairford abandonment is really a US failure. If there is a legitimate need for reexamination in the UK, then the the senior party needs it as well for the same reasons.
As to the “systems” article, the mismatch between US military systems and the threats they face are more due to the politics/economics of the dysfunctional US procurement system than the hardware. We have several decades of failed military projects that don’t address the military threats of the future. But they would similarly be hard pressed to address the military threats of the past. Where funds get spent became more important than the capacity of the system.
For example, the US still doesn’t have adequate counters to large scale mine laying. That’s a threat that’s been around since the Crimean War.
UK and France have SLBM subs. I guess we’d find out how good our fasties are trying to disarm either country. Relying on British and French traitors to save us is probably not a terrific plan. On the other had if we stood aside during a Euro-Russian nuclear war, that would at least clear the air (so to speak)! Maybe that’s what the talks with Xi are about. We get Europe, Africa, and you get Asia and Australia.
And, of course, regime change in Mexico, Brazil, Cuba and Canada, and we’ve got the New World back. Maybe pay Elon to hurry our claims to the Moon, Mars, and Callisto, with Jeffy as a Plan B?