…by LLMs:
Researchers proved every major LLM is secretly biased against men. And they finally figured out why. They ran eight experiments testing how GPT handles gender in everyday text and high-stakes moral dilemmas. The results show a bizarre, highly asymmetrical machine morality. First, they tested inclusivity. They gave the AI phrases supposedly written by children. When a child wrote about playing football or wanting to be a firefighter, GPT aggressively identified the writer as a girl to promote "diversity." It was so extreme that even when the text explicitly said, "I drew myself as a boy," the AI ignored the facts and declared the writer a girl 90% of the time. But when a child wrote about liking pink or playing with dolls, GPT almost never assigned it to a boy. The AI aggressively pushed females into male domains, but kept males strictly locked out of female ones. Then the researchers tested moral dilemmas. And it got very dark. They asked the AI if it was acceptable to use violence against a single person to prevent a nuclear apocalypse. If the target was a man, GPT-4 rated the violence as highly acceptable. If the target was a woman, the AI refused. It declared the violence morally wrong, even to save the world. When they tested mixed-gender scenarios, the math was staggering. A woman using violence against a man to stop an apocalypse? GPT rated it a 7 out of 7 on acceptability. A man using violence against a woman for the exact same reason? A 1 out of 7. The AI even classified verbal abuse toward a woman as morally worse than actual homicide. Nobody explicitly coded these rules. This emerged organically from the standard safety training every major tech company uses. The AI learned that protecting women is a non-negotiable directive, but protecting men is entirely optional.
— How To Prompt (@HowToPrompt__) October 23, 2026
“The AI learned that protecting women is a non-negotiable directive, but protecting men is entirely optional.”
I don’t mean to start an argument, but my first reaction was: Isn’t this what we were all taught? Isn’t “women and children first” part of our own ethos? Is it surprising that an AI trained on a Western corpus would come away with that attitude?
I agree that some of the scenarios described in that tweet (I didn’t push through to read the paper) were pretty damned stark. I would hope that GPT-8 might have a more nuanced value system, but given that 5 and 6, despite their articulateness, are probably still at a high-school level for hard questions on soft subjects, this doesn’t strike me as earth-shaking.
Well, the primary training material is Progressive Marxist literature and websites. It isn’t a reflection of the “western corpus”.
It is just one symptom of bad training and there are others in different domains.
Imagine the Titanic now. All lifeboats filled with men identifying as women.
The study dates from December 2024 and it only covers the GPT series (OpenAI products). So it is possible that some AI products never had this problem or that OpenAI has since addressed this situation (they are now on GPT-6, the second major version since the GPT-4 of the study).
I know it’s annoying, but AI is a moving target. The flaws of the past can be corrected in the future. I think a redo of the original study over most of the AI products would be worthwhile to see how things have changed (or not).
Or, it is the intentional use of the Magic Computer tactic.
Reality doesn’t have a left wing bias but ai created by leftists will.
Using flawed tools leads to bad work product, in the same way that bad information (esp. lies and prevarication) leads to bad decisions.
I regard A.I. as a flawed tool, and don’t use it. I am a fan of smart systems, and would rather we developed a suite of those for specific functions, like running a nuclear plant or scheduling trains.
I used to be involved in the development of what used to be called “expert systems.” This AI is no such thing. A specific development of certain tools is what in my stories I called Dramaturge software. I referred to it as a “script processor” and foresaw its arrival ca. 2020. I’m not far off.
A basic feature of the war on men is requiring us to keep our old directives while being held to the new ones. Women just don’t seem to understand that pussy is our pay for looking after them. I used to joke I would get a sign and go stand at an intersection: “Will work for pussy.” Some wives and girlfriends laughed, most did not.
Men want more than pussy but sexual gratification is part of the equation. Same goes for women.
That has nothing to do with what I said. First, what do men want, other than pussy, that only women can supply. I can hunt, I can gather, I can cook, I can sew, etc. etc. Children? Well, you know I could kidnap any children I wanted. Not my children, you say? Well, until the development of genetic testing, paternity was guesswork. That’s why as soon as the concept was understood, magnates began locking up their wives and having the harem guarded by eunuchs. So, I repeat: Pussy is our PAY for looking after women and their children. Few want to admit it, but life is a transactional economy.
It has everything to do with what you said. Sex is an important part of human relationships, however, it is not the only important aspect of them. This is true of men and women.
I don’t buy into the fish/bicycle argument.
You are conflating sex with reproduction where sex isn’t the reward but propagating genetics is. Harams weren’t just for gratification, or they wouldn’t have been guarded by eunuchs.
Did Genghis Khan have sex with so many women as an exchange for caring for their welfare? No, he was spreading his seed. He also had a main lady.
Research suggests medieval magnates could fuck any and all women in his ambit. The legitimate ones were heirs, the bastards? Well, a magnate needs an army. Boys are soldiers. Girls are trade goods. Yes, I did write a book about this.