Category Archives: War Commentary

War Commentary

He Forgot One

I agree that we’re in a new world war (and the third in a row that is a fundamental clash of ideologies), but I wish that Newt would stop calling it World War III. It’s World War IV. World War III was the Cold War. And unfortunately, this one may last almost as long.

[Update]

I should note this (a couple years old, and quite long) essay by Norman Podhoretz on this issue.

[Late morning update]

If we’re in a long world war, then it makes no sense to talk about the “war” in Iraq. It was only a battle, as was Afghanistan, as Larry Schweikart points out:

The supposed value of history is that it allows one to apply a long-term lens perspective to current events. That, however, seems to be sadly missing in the case of the War on Terror, and, especially, Iraq. Let me say from the get-go that the Bush Administration erred badly in allowing the struggle in Iraq to be labeled a “war.” It is a battle, part of the larger War on Terror. It is no more a “war” than Sicily or North Africa were “wars.” But Bush fell into the Left’s trap and allowed it to be called a “war,” and as such it has been separated from the “War on Terror,” and the “War in Afghanistan,” itself a battle.

As historians (objective ones, that is) look back 30 years from now, and write the history of this war, they will find the battle of Iraq essentially was over after November 2004. I do not say that because Bush won reelection–that was critical, but so was the formation of the Iraqi government at that time–but because those two events then allowed a military victory at Fallujah, which was the tipping point of this battle (or, if you prefer, “war”). At Fallujah, more than 2000 terrorists were killed and the real al-Qaeda back of the so-called “insurgency” broken. Since then, Zarqawi was scrambling, as did the Japanese after Okinawa, to re-stock his ranks of suicide bombers. They were both unsuccessful. Last month, Zarqawi was killed, replicating the shooting down of Admiral Isoroku Yamamoto’s plane in 1943. Even then, the war in the Pacific was not over–and the bloodiest battles had not been fought–but again, the outcome was further cemented.

And he’s optimistic that we’re going to ultimately win. I hope he’s right.

War Commentary

The Other Lone Star State

2 Comments

Don’t mess with Knesset…

…we have had the Yom Kippur War, the Attrition War, the Lebanon War, two intifadas and endless terror. Israel has not only survived, but has become stronger. It is a vibrant and prospering democracy, with robust economic growth over the last five years, the highest number of books published per capita in the world, and second place in the world in the publication of articles in scientific journals.

The Arabs, in the meantime, with all their aggression, have only brought on their peoples misery and poverty. President Anwar Sadat of Egypt and King Hussein of Jordan tower above this self-destructiveness as leaders who really served the best interests of their people by making peace with Israel.

Of course, that’s just a necessary, not a sufficient condition, as we’ve seen by the dismal state of affairs in both countries, but particularly Egypt.

[Credit for slogan and flag to “Dutchgirl” (who’s really a Dane–no shock there)–scroll down to the sixth post]

War Commentary

Can Anyone Explain To Me

…why we should take the IAEA seriously?

Mohammad El-Baradei’s capitulation to Iran has made huge waves at the IAEA in Vienna. The other inspectors are up in arms. “This totally bankrupts our work” says a Viennese inspector. “Mohammad El-Baradei folds vis-a-vis the Mullahs and leaves us standing in the rain. Why don’t we just let Iran be in charge of inspecting their own nuclear program?”