Did The US Sabotage The Russian Mars Probe?

Ummmmmm…no:

Rogozin, at least, admitted that a far more plausible cause was a failure on the spacecraft itself. “Practially all disruptions are due to flaws in the technologies manufactured 12 to 13 years ago,” he said. And a new and highly plausible report issued today further supports the leading theory: that the craft’s autopilot software had never been adequately debugged. The probe’s chief scientist, Alexander Zakharov, also denounced the interference theory as “exotic” and “disingenuous.”

The Russians have space tracking blind spots around the world because they scrapped their sea-going tracking ships years ago, and closed down other ground sites. The space program’s tracking ability is so limited that shortly before the launch of Fobos-Grunt, a program scientist emailed amateur astronomers in South America, asking them to go outside when the probe was passing overhead and report whether its rocket was firing on time. (It wasn’t, as it turned out.)

And as for Kwajalein, scientists familiar with worldwide radar tracking of asteroids assure me they’ve never heard of any participation by radars based there. If asked, they would have told Kommersant the same thing.

Sadly, this knee-jerk blame shifting in the space industry has ramped up in recent years. The real danger in the Russian nonsense about finding the United States at fault for the crash isn’t just the blow to diplomacy and public attitudes. Also important is how such claims prevent a proper investigation and get in the way of implementing a reliable “fix.”

Phantom “causes” lead to delusional, even damaging, responses. That raises the level of danger to which everybody whose lives depend on Russian spacecraft—and that now includes U.S. and other astronauts—is exposed.

Yup. And it’s looking more and more like it was a software problem.

7 thoughts on “Did The US Sabotage The Russian Mars Probe?”

  1. I think the Phobos spacecraft was just collateral damage. The real target was the Chinese Mars mission so they don’t take any new pictures of the face on Mars 🙂

  2. Thomas, you were SO close. I have it on the best authority (igNobel prize winner Richard C. Hoagland) that the dastardly doers of this deed were none other than those irrepressible space Nazis. That’s right, the same villains who plagued a group of teenage geniuses in Heinlein’s nonfiction classic “Rocketship Galileo”, have reached out with their super science and swept Phobos Grunt from the sky. This is just one more battle in the ongoing secret space war.

  3. Yeah, those “commercial” space guys are such a profit-driven, corner-cutting menace that we should NEVER risk the lives of our astronauts in their death-trap “spaceships.”. Better to stick with level-headed, technically savvy folks like the Russians, who always have a perfect handle on what’s happening with their space systems…

    1. Most folks view computer programming like magic, something that “wizards” say up late at to night to “conjure up”, so its easy to place blame on what you don’t understand.

Comments are closed.