The Real War Has Finally Begun

A good analysis of what’s been happening over the past day in Iran.

It seemed pretty clear that something was going to happen when we evacuated embassies in the region.

[Update early afternoon]

Iran has been launching retaliatory missile strikes against Tel Aviv, with most of them intercepted. I don’t think I’d want to be on Kharg Island on any day, but definitely not today.

24 thoughts on “The Real War Has Finally Begun”

  1. “Our president will start a war with Iran cause he absolutely has no ability to negotiate he’s weak and he’s ineffective.” Barack Obama

    1. I’m sure the people in Iran who revolted against the regime – expecting help from Obama and who died because he didn’t give it – have their own notions of weak and ineffective.

      1. Well of course the ones who survived have their own notions of weak and ineffective (Wish I could edit these).

  2. Iran, it seems to me, is now in an interesting position.

    Iran’s main choice at this juncture is to decide whether to just hit Israel (such as the ballistic missile attack today) or, hit one or more US facilities in the region as well as Israel.

    One might think that, seeing as they’re losing to Israel, Iran might not be overly eager to draw the US (which has both more capabilities, and more convenient bases) into the war on Israel’s side. However, it’s not that simple.

    The Iranian regime has been very vitriolic in its statements about the US. The regime also has domestic worries (a population where the majority hates them). Those domestic worries (possible revolution) likely trump their military worries. So, my guess is, they might seriously consider striking US targets to make themselves look strong to their domestic audience.

    Their hope would be to get a casualty count to paint as a “win”. Their further hope would be that the US would settle for playing a weak tit-for-tat response, and that’d be that.

    So, I think it’s possible (though far from likely or certain) that Iran will hit US targets. They might even go for a terror attack in the US. I think doing either would be a miscalculation of their part. However, from the regime’s point of view, a slim hope is better than none, so if they see it as lessening the chance of a revolution, they might think it best to roll the dice.

    All I’m saying is I hope the US has its eyes very much open, both domestically and in the middle east, in case this occurs. Looks to me like we do, but, it’s always a concern.

      1. 200% agreed, Rand! Not only would we be less likely to take the threat seriously a year ago, it would’ve been more likely to occur due to our idiotic “proportional response” policy.

        I’ve never understood why telling your enemy that you’ll, at worst, hit them back only as hard as they hit you counts as deterrence. It’s actually the opposite.

        BTW, Iran just directly threatened the US (without naming it) by declaring that they’ll attack anyone helping to defend Israel. I’m pretty sure this is in response to Tehran residents currently chanting “Death to dictator” and “Death to Khamenei”. My current take is that the odds of the scenario I worried about in my original post are going up; the regime, due to their domestic concerns, could well prefer dragging the US into the war. A further factor is that they’re the type that, if they know they’re going down, would prefer to drag as many with them as they can. My current guess is the odds of Iran hitting US assets are now just over 50%.

  3. Remember not long ago many smart guys fell for the Ukraine is winning Russia is getting wiped out propaganda videos? Don’t feel you may have seen this movie before? AI deep fakes are so much better than they were just 2 years ago.

    1. If you think Russia is winning its disastrous war with Ukraine you are definitely not one of the “smart guys.” Do you think Ukraine’s Operation Spider’s Web was, somehow, a great Russian victory? Every day that passes, Ukraine’s ability to savage Russia’s interior increases and Russia’s ability to defend decreases. It’s not a question of whether Russia loses the war, just a question of when.

      Here’s another little something for you to chew on. Most of the drones Russia now sends against Ukraine are supplied by Iran. Where is Russia going to get more of those once Israel has ground Iran into powder?

      The imminent fall of one notorious scumbag nation will contribute to, and accelerate, the fall of another.

      1. If you think Russia is winning its disastrous war with Ukraine you are definitely not one of the “smart guys.”

        Ha I thought I heard from someone with authority and access to intel 3 months ago, that Ukraine is not in a good position that doesn’t have a card to play and they are gambling with World War 3. They are running low on soldiers. They should take any cease fire they are offered.
        So who am I to believe ?

          1. You are the voluntary “victim” of a psyop that Russia and its apologists have been trying to run since Feb. 2022, namely that Russia is in the right, will inevitably win and that Ukraine will dry up and blow away Real Soon Now. Said psyop has long since ceased to have even token credibility except among true-believing dead-enders such as yourself.

          2. Dick, it is possible to believe both that Russia is in the wrong, and that in a war of attrition the country with 5x the population of its opponent would win.

        1. That same guy has also said that EV trucks weigh too much and are inferior to ICE trucks. There has, as yet, been no “road to Damascus” moment for him on that particular issue, but there certainly has been anent Ukraine.

          He’s not saying now what he said three months ago, he’s saying pretty much nothing. But he’s pretty obviously no longer under the mistaken impression that Putin is his good buddy and someone he can deal with. There’s also no longer any big talk about ending the Russo-Ukraine war in jig time. And the US aid has long since started flowing to Ukraine again and with even fewer restrictions than before. He’s also said zippity doo dah about French troops being on the ground in Ukraine.

          Something else we don’t hear about anymore is turning Gaza into a beach resort. He has a lot of experience in the hospitality industries and seems to have figured out that a population of homicidal psychopaths isn’t exactly an ideal base to draw on for waitresses, bellmen, valets and cabana boys.

          The one really big difference between Trump and any randomly selected lefty is that he’s educable. He doesn’t double down and push even harder when an idea is obviously not working.

          That’s because, for good or ill, he’s neither an intellectual nor an ideologue. Thus far, the good aspects of that have outweighed the ill. I expect that to continue.

      2. Oh, I saw it on TV so it must be true. According to the TV Iran supplied Russia with the Shaheed drone 2 years ago and since then the Russians improved the design, added a jet engine and are calling it the Geran. All made in Russia, allegedly.

        I have a BIL that consults for a defense think tank part time. He reads lots of studies and he’s certain he knows everything. He never seems to question who wrote those studies and why.

        1. The Russians were making – or at least trying to make – some Shaheeds domestically. Ukraine blew up the factory a month or so back.

          Ukraine is doing to Russia pretty much what the RAF and the 8th Air Force did to the Third Reich back in the day – smashing Russian military and military-adjacent industry to flinders. Energy industry was the initial big target but now it seems to be pretty much anything having to do with military production – notably assembly plants of many kinds and semiconductor fabs recently.

          As Russia continues to lose even what little anti-air capability it still has, Ukraine will more and more employ manned aircraft as well as drones to do these jobs. That’s already happening to a modest degree. Russia’s last functional A-50 appears to have been among the casualties of Operation Spider’s Web and every variety of Russian anti-air missile system is now in rapidly shortening supply. The Ukrainians destroy them as soon as they are found and they have all proven incapable even of self-defense.

          Absent the death of Putin or an utter collapse and rout of the Russian army, the war could well continue for another two years or so. About all Russia can now do is, to some degree, pick the date on which it will be forced to yield.

          Anent your BIL, I get the impression all of those studies he reads fail to accord with your own takes on current events. If not, I assume you would have said otherwise. I am, to put it mildly, not an admirer of the US intelligence apparat. But I guess it’s good to know that, even there, not everyone drinks the pro-Russian Kool-Aid.

  4. The Israel-Iran war is looking like a speeded-up version of the last 18 months or so of WW2 in the European Theater of Operations. At that point, Germany no longer had an air force capable of hitting England. Iran barely has an air force at all. But Germany could still hit England with V-1s and V-2s. Iran can still hit Israel with ballistic rockets. The RAF and the US 8th Air Force were busily pounding the Third Reich into rubble including launch sites for Nazi rockets. The Israeli Air Force is busily doing the same to Iran. Unlike the analogous phase of WW2, though, the current Israel-Iran war is not going to take anywhere near 18 months to conclude. 18 days will probably be more like it.

  5. For the last 80 years (Post-WW2), the US has had a bad habit of snatching defeat from the jaws of victory, so we’ll see what happens next. As for a terror attack on the US awakening the Woke, well 9/11 didn’t really do it. I mean. remember how we “wiped out” the Taliban? Oopsie-daisy.

    1. We’ve had some successes since WW2 but I will readily acknowledge the numerous failures as well – especially post-1960 when the US government became more and more a plaything of the Ivy League.

      In the present day, however, that is largely irrelevant. Our involvement in the Russo-Ukraine war is pretty much like our pre-Pearl Harbor involvement in WW2 – we’re sending “Lend-Lease” and intelligence to Ukraine and that’s about it.

      We have even less involvement in the Israel-Gaza and Israel-Iran wars. Given that the US military/intelligence “communities” are not in consequential charge of anything about those two conflicts, our track record is moot – these two wars are not part of our record.

      Trump was certainly inclined to do something Bush-ily or Obama-ly stupid anent Ukraine when he first took office, but subsequent events appear to have bitch-slapped some sense into him and disabused him of any former tendencies toward imagining himself some sort of peacemaker by decree. His involvement in Israel’s two wars has been minimal. One hopes it stays that way and I see no reason to expect otherwise.

      Israel simply needs to be left alone to complete the extermination of Hamas and Hezbollah plus the military neutering and regime changing of Iran. The second of these wars will make the successful completion of the first quicker and more final.

      It will also materially assist the Ukraine against Russia – no more Iranian armaments going to its enemy.

    1. Yes, I have. Now when are you going to see a neurologist about the fact that your brain doesn’t work?

      Or almost doesn’t work. It still seems to work well enough to know to change the subject when its owner is getting his rhetorical clock cleaned. In the immortal words of W.C. Fields, “Ah, look over there – a buffalo stampede.”

Leave a Reply to Brinksedge Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *